There are so many issues caused by training dogs with treats, but if you train dogs properly with food, you won’t have any issues at all. And herein lies the problem, and why food has such a terrible reputation in so many different dog-related contexts.
Let’s start with the big misconceptions, then I’ll share why they’re true, but why they’re also not…
5 truths about training dogs with food:
Truth 1: Training with food causes over-arousal / crazy behaviour.
This is absolutely true if the food is insanely high value or has been withheld or restricted and if the dog is frustrated, only does very exciting things with food, or is driven to learn past the handler’s capability to channel that energy into learning.
Any dog can train with food, and the drive to learn creates speed and enthusiasm that can be easily harnessed if the handler is good at their timing and reward frequencies. This is a truth, with some dogs, in some situations, but it is certainly not true in most cases, with proper training, structure and the use of the correct value of food for the dog (raw beef mince might send a Labrador scatty vs kibble with the same dog, for example).
Truth 2: Training with food doesn’t work, because if the dog is in a pheasant pen/dog park/<insert other place>, it all goes out the window.
This is absolutely true if the training hasn’t been done right and if food hasn’t been faded out from basic behaviour chains.
This sounds really complicated, but picture this:
If you took a dog who could do a 10-second sit and stay in the kitchen into a pheasant or rabbit pen, and asked them to sit and stay with all the small furries running about, then the dog won’t be able to do a sit and stay there. No dog would do that. It is insane to expect anything different.
A dog trained a sit and stay with only food can and will sit perfectly well in a pheasant pen. They’d have worked on the behaviour under a gradual build of distractions, and at this stage in a dog’s training, food would have been faded out for another reinforcer, as is done with correct reinforcement training.
^^ This is exactly the same as if you weren’t training with food, there is no difference here (sorry!).
Truth 3: If you use treats to train your dog, they’ll only listen when you've got food with you.
This is absolutely true if the handler doesn’t have an understanding of training dogs with food.
There is no and-if on this one. I’ll explain…
This is the most common thing people say about training dogs with food, and it shows a huge misunderstanding of the difference between training and bribing, accidentally falling into the trap of the latter, and not having attempted to fade food or apply real-world reinforcers to the training progression.
Again, this all sounds complicated, but if every time you asked your dog to do something you do it with food in your hand, the day you don’t have food in your hand and don’t reach for a hidden morsel of food is also the day you inadvertently trained your dog that having food visible is the only way to be rewarded.
Dogs who do not listen to their humans unless they have food visible are dogs who were trained to only listen when food was present - they learnt something, just not what was intended.
That’s not a bad dog, that’s bad training.
The purpose of food in dog training:
If training with food, the food should be a reinforcer that increases the chance of the dog repeating a behaviour, that’s all.
It should be the job of a marker (“Yes!”) to say what we want repeated, and food just reinforces that message. The marker takes the weight of showing what was right, the food backs it up.
Food does not and should not be visible when the dog already knows what is being asked - it can just come out to say, “Hey, that was still right; keep doing that when I ask you to”.
Food ≠ bribery, and if it does for any particular dog, their handler just needs a few training sessions to fix their reward protocol, that’s all ❤️
If you want to learn all about markers, there is a free PDF guide and 3-part mini email course here.
Truth 4: Training with treats makes dogs fat/is bad for their health
This is absolutely true if the handler doesn’t re-portion the dogs meals and if they use treats, cheese or other options for training.
I used to be a handler who used cheese, meat and commercial treats. I was lured in by the marketing and other people who said to use these things, but for the last 8 years, I’ve used the dogs meals as the training, and as they’re all pre-portioned out, there is no additional caloric gain or unhealthy extras here.
If the dog has a low food drive, we work on that for a couple of days. And whilst food drive for the dogs normal meals (raw or kibble) is being built up, I will occasionally use some cooked chicken to plug the gap for a day or two, as we did with Renegade the Malinois when she came home at 8 weeks old. Very, very quickly, we’re onto their normal meals being used for training.
If the dog struggles to concentrate or refuses to eat their kibble/meals in a specific environment, the problem is not the type of food, it’s the arousal or desensitisation to distractions that is. Again, this is a training problem, not a food problem.
Using our method, which creates super drive for normal boring kibble, the dogs can have extras now and then like a chicken foot here, a lamb neck there, but they don’t have any commercial dog treats because doing so would mean we have to re-calculate meals. For us it adds an extra variable for a couple of our dogs who have severe food allergies (Alf) or sensitive stomachs (rescue Zest).
So, it is impossible for this truth to be true for us here.
Truth 5: Using food in dog training is just bribing them
This is absolutely true if the handler doesn’t understand how to use food in training (see Truth 3) and if the dog isn’t being rewarded for making their own choices, but is instead being co-erced with food to complete the task due to the ‘bribe’.
I won’t repeat the explanation for Truth 3 again, but to cover off the second part, there is an element of agency here. If the dog really wants the food and the only option is to get the food, alternatives are not an option - either through fear, pain or it literally cannot be done due to physical barriers or restraints, then yes, I suppose it is bribing? Maybe? This logic is a reach, it’s not grounded in anything, so I can’t go either way here.
If the food is used after a marker, without it being present, to reward a behaviour on the basis that it is more likely to be repeated in the future, that is not a bribe. It is simply being used as a reinforcer, like praise, like doing the retrieve again, like anything else the dog likes.
If the food is being used a lure, in the context of luring, the food is faded out as quickly as possible and put onto a cue, with no bribe present, then it would also not be a bribe.
Lots of thought paths going on there, but I suppose that’s 5 truths!
Learn how:
If you want to know the truth about food, why it works, how to use it with your own dog and how to stay away from the trap of bribing your dog, you can grab the free PDF below.
If you want to know how to:
Build your dogs food drive for their normal meals, plus;
Avoid my husband Dan’s mistake, which left him with zero recall after using food for training…
… then don’t panic; you’ll get the 3-part mini course included with that guide above, so just check your inbox.
You can unsubscribe at any time, so no pressure there!
Hope this helped fill in some blanks 🙌